Reexamining the Intricacies of Adverbs: A Guide on Appropriate Usage (and When to Avoid Them)
In the world of writing, the humble adverb has been a subject of much debate. Some argue that adverbs can sometimes insult the reader by not trusting their intelligence, while others believe they are a necessary tool for adding meaning and clarifying how an action is performed.
The pairing of weak verbs with fluffy adverbs often results in telling rather than showing in writing. Strong verbs, on the other hand, are often able to stand on their own without the need for adverbs. However, adverbs can be effective when they change the meaning of a phrase, such as "killing me softly."
Criticism of adverbs is not limited to individual writers; English professors, journalists, and best-selling authors have also condemned them. Stephen King, a renowned author, has expressed his criticism towards adverbs, stating that "The road to hell is paved with adverbs." In his book "On Writing," he provides examples of over-clarification using adverbs.
Adverbs are often criticized for being the weakest of the four parts of speech: nouns, verbs, adjectives, and adverbs. They are accused of weakening prose through redundancy, unnecessary emphasis, and overuse, which can make writing less clear and less precise.
Writers are advised to avoid superfluous modifiers such as adverbs like "completely" in phrases like "completely finished" because the adjective alone suffices. Overused adverbs like “incredibly” or “extremely” often add emphasis without contributing substantive meaning, resulting in redundancy or tautology. Adverbs can be a crutch that reduces the writer’s ability to choose more precise verbs or adjectives, which can strengthen a sentence more effectively than simply adding an adverb.
However, adverbs are considered useful when they genuinely add meaning or clarify how an action is performed, especially when a strong verb alone does not provide sufficient detail or nuance. For example, adverbs can intensify emotion ("She was incredibly happy") or specify manner, time, place, or degree when such precision is necessary. Therefore, judicious use of adverbs that contribute to clarity without redundancy is recommended, rather than eliminating them altogether.
In summary, adverbs are useful when they enhance meaning and clarity but are often discouraged when overused or when they create redundancy, signaling a need for stronger word choice instead. While they might lend themselves to boring verbs in many cases, they can also act as a crutch for weak verbs. The key lies in using them sparingly and with caution, as they are just one tool among many in the writer's arsenal.
[1] Roy Peter Clark, "Writing Tools: 55 Essential Strategies for Every Writer" [2] Stephen King, "On Writing: A Memoir of the Craft" [4] The Chicago Manual of Style, 17th edition
The lifestyle of a writer involves careful selection of words for effective communication. In this regard, home-and-garden magazines could offer valuable insights, as their focus on precise choices of words and images to engage readers may translate to the writer's utilization of adverbs.
Criticizing the use of adverbs is not unique to the writing world; it parallels the debates in home-and-garden publishing about the appropriate use of adjectives and other modifiers to ensure clarity and precision for readers.
){kind=link}