Comparing Metal and Cedar Shingles: Advantages and Disadvantages in Roofing Material Choices
In the world of roofing, two popular choices stand out: standing seam metal roofs and cedar shake roofs. Each offers unique benefits and drawbacks, making the choice between the two a significant decision for any homeowner or builder.
Durability
Standing seam metal roofs are renowned for their exceptional longevity, often lasting 50 years or more with proper maintenance. They are resistant to fire, decay, and can withstand extreme weather conditions such as wind, rain, and hail. On the other hand, cedar shake roofs have a typical lifespan of 30 to 40 years, and they are susceptible to weather damage, rot, insects, and fire unless specially treated.
Maintenance
Standing seam metal roofs require minimal maintenance, with occasional inspections sufficing. They are resistant to moss, mildew, and insect damage. In contrast, cedar shake roofs demand regular maintenance, including cleaning, sealing, and treatment to prevent rot and insect damage. This can be a labor-intensive task.
Energy Efficiency
Standing seam metal roofs reflect sunlight, reducing heat absorption and cooling costs. They can be combined with insulation for better energy performance and may qualify for energy tax credits. Cedar shake roofs, however, are poorer insulators and typically absorb more heat, potentially increasing cooling costs.
Aesthetics
Standing seam metal roofs offer a sleek, modern appearance with large, thin metal panels. They are available in a variety of colours and finishes, including options that mimic the look of cedar shakes without sacrificing durability. Cedar shake roofs, on the other hand, provide a natural, rustic look that many homeowners find appealing. They offer a traditional aesthetic that metal tries to mimic but never fully replicates the authentic wood texture.
Cost
Standing seam metal roofs have a higher upfront cost, approximately $15 per square foot for standing seam metal, and require skilled labour for installation. However, their longer lifespan reduces the total lifecycle cost. Cedar shake roofs have a lower initial cost, but the ongoing maintenance and shorter lifespan increase the lifetime expense.
Environmental Impact
Standing seam metal roofs are more environmentally friendly due to their high recycled content and full recyclability at the end of their life, reducing landfill waste compared to asphalt or cedar roofs replaced frequently. Cedar shake roofs, however, have a greater environmental impact over their lifecycle due to wood harvesting and more frequent replacement.
A Compromise: Metal Roofs That Mimic Cedar Shakes
Metal roofing variants that mimic cedar shakes can be an effective compromise. They offer controlled aesthetics with metal’s performance benefits, providing an appealing alternative for those seeking a middle ground between the two options.
Contact Heather and Little for Your Roofing Needs
Whether you're leaning towards a roof with standing seam metal shingles or cedar shingles, Heather and Little has the expertise to bring your roofing vision to life for a roof replacement or restoration. Contact us today to schedule a consultation for a new roof for your building.
[1] "Standing Seam Metal Roofing: Pros and Cons." HomeAdvisor, 2021, www.homeadvisor.com/r/standing-seam-metal-roofing-pros-and-cons/
[2] "Standing Seam Metal Roof Costs." Roofing Calculator, 2021, www.roofingcalculator.com/costs/standing-seam-metal-roof-costs/
[3] "Metal Roofing vs. Cedar Shake Roofing: Which is Right for Your Home?" Angie's List, 2021, www.angieslist.com/articles/metal-roofing-vs-cedar-shake-roofing-which-is-right-for-your-home.htm
[4] "Cedar Shake Roofing: Pros and Cons." HomeAdvisor, 2021, www.homeadvisor.com/r/cedar-shake-roofing-pros-and-cons/
[5] "Environmental Impact of Metal Roofing." Metal Roofing Alliance, 2021, www.metalroofing.com/environmental-impact/
Standing seam metal shingles, with their sleek design and excellent durability, can be an appealing compromise for those seeking a modern aesthetic while still prioritizing longevity, energy efficiency, and low maintenance. In terms of lifestyle and home-and-garden choices, homeowners may find that metal roofs cater to a more contemporary and low-maintenance ethos, providing a cost-effective long-term solution for their home-improvement projects.
